Paula asked this question recently on FB.
A few days ago, I read the start of
a novel on Amazon (using the ‘Look Inside’ facility) as it was set in Ireland
and looked interesting. It also had 20+ good reviews. However, I decided not to
buy it. Why? Because there was too much narrative, description, and backstory
in the first few pages. Following this, I posed the question on FB and received
about 30 replies giving different reasons why people didn’t buy a book
after reading the Amazon excerpt. Here's a summary of the comments:
Inevitably quite a few people
mentioned bad grammar or poor editing, or more generally ‘bad writing’. Linked
to this, ‘style’ could be a deal breaker. Obviously this is subjective, as not
every writer’s style will appeal to every reader, but some commenters felt it
was important that the style, rhythm, or quality of writing appealed to them.
One person referred to this as the ‘character’s voice’.
Another major off-putting
factor was too much description in the first few pages - phrases used were ‘superfluous
description’, ‘overabundance of exposition’, or ‘painfully describing every
detail’. Info dumps and blatant factual research were also disliked, as was
‘all telling’ and too much backstory at the beginning of the story. However,
one commenter said: “sometimes the author doesn’t give enough back story and
you’re lost from the get go.”
Readers didn’t like
slow-paced stories that failed to make much progression in the first few pages.
The need to be ‘grabbed’ was important.
In some cases, dialogue could
be the make or break factor. One person commented on ‘discussions about
nothing,’ while another disliked ‘too much dialog where the things the characters
say gives you no insight into their personalities’. Both of these could be
summed up as ‘waffling’.
Point of View switches came
in for some criticism. Several disliked too many switches of POV, referred to
as ‘bouncing’ or ‘ping-pong’ switches (even though, as one person pointed out, Nora Roberts does this all
the time).
Other commenters were put off
by: violence for the sake of violence, too many unpronounceable names,
unlikeable characters, two-dimensional characters, too many characters introduced too quickly, too many adverbs, and four
letter words. A couple of people also disliked stories written in first person
present tense.
So there you have it. Now you
know what to include (or rather what not to include!) in your first few pages.
The ‘Look Inside’ facility is the one that seems to be universally used, and it
is this, and not the cover or blurb, that will persuade your readers to buy
your book - or not!
Great post, Paula, and an excellent reminder why those openings have to be spot on and grab the reader right from the beginning.
ReplyDeleteThe first sentence can be important but most people read past that, so I'd probably say it's the first couple of pages that should grab.
DeleteI'm not sure I have a specific reason why I don't enjoy a book. I think in general it's a feeling I get that it's just not for me.
ReplyDeleteI think it's probably a combination of several things - some practical like grammar etc - but others less tangible, like whether the style of writing appeals to you, or the opening scene etc.
DeleteThanks for this, Paula. Lots of useful points to bear in mind. I think a lot of people, like Jennifer, go for their feeling about it and, as you say, it often comes down to a combination of several things. As with so much connected with writing, the more you read, the more you can get a sense of what works.
ReplyDeleteLilian B
I agree, Lilian. I usually know within the first couple of ages whether it's 'my' kind of book. Thanks for visiting HWH :-)
DeleteWhat a great insight, Paula. I do read the opening snippets and form a judgment. The author's style either hooks me or not. I do read, but don't put as much stock in reviews.
ReplyDeleteI tend to look more at the 1 and 2 star reviews than the 5 stars!
DeleteHere's a blog that says more or the less the same as mine! http://marcykennedy.com/2015/06/10-writing-mistakes-that-kill-your-first-chapter/
ReplyDelete